How About Some Self Discipline
Last month, I decided to pay for a month of The Dying Breed, a Substack by the team behind The Art of Manliness. After a couple of years of advertising, I figured I'd gamble my five dollars in hopes of finding enough content to justify the expense. The verdict... ehh, yeah, it was worth five bucks, just not every month.
I've never been much of a Substack user, so the past month has been interesting. The site does a pretty good job of recommending similar content, and I found some decent blogs that I wouldn't normally run across. Stuff created by individuals who aren't particularly tech-savvy and don't necessarily care about the IndieWeb side of things, but also folks who are all about monetizing EVERYTHING. It truly feels like the middle ground between social media and blogging.
Somehow, I read something that convinced the algorithm I wanted to read all about going analog or getting a dumb phone. I'll admit, in the past this would have really interested me. I've spent plenty of time experimenting with dumb phones and going analog over the years, just not recently.
As I read through these blogs, I find it fascinating that folks are coming to the same conclusions about phone exhaustion and lack of ownership that others reached over a decade ago. These aren't new ideas, but it seems a new generation is just discovering them.
Like myself several years ago, these folks go through extraordinary lengths to be "offline," only to share every element of the experience online. I remember swapping SIM cards, fighting with MP3s, utilizing website blockers, and the like. I spent so much time trying not to be online that being offline became part of who I was. In a strange way, it began to define me, and I always found that a bit ridiculous. I didn't want a new label. I just wanted to cut back on my unhealthy use of technology.
After spending hundreds of dollars, watching a bazillion YouTube videos, and writing dozens of blog posts, I finally came to the conclusion that none of this was getting me where I wanted to be. It was just creating more headaches and frustrations.
That's when I realized that all the time and energy I was putting into purchasing "old tech" could be better spent building up a little self-discipline. How about instead of swapping to a dumb phone on the weekends, I just... I don't know, turn my smartphone off? How about I leave it at home when I run to the store? How about I uninstall the apps that I spend too much time on? If you can't turn your devices off and sit comfortably, then you have a much bigger problem that buying a dumb phone is not going to fix.
It took me years, and a lot of trial and error, but I eventually realized I was chasing something that didn't exist. I was participating in a new form of capitalism, and possibly indulging in some unhealthy habits of chasing the past. Instead, I should have been asking myself the real question: Why do I feel like technology is a problem, and how can I change the way I use it?
I guess I should remember that so much of this is performative, and Substack seems to have plenty of that sort of thing going on. After all, just as you get halfway through a post about simplifying your life and escaping the endless cycle of consumption, you're greeted with a huge ad asking you to pay for a monthly subscription. It's funny, it reminds me of just one more way to simplify my online life, by not subscribing.